Skip to content
Tanner
Preserve
All guides
AI and automation

How to show up when someone asks ChatGPT who to hire

8 min readUpdated July 1, 2026
01

How AI assistants decide who to recommend

When someone asks ChatGPT "who's a good plumber near Oconomowoc," the AI doesn't have a secret list of approved companies. It runs a web search, reads what comes back (business profiles, review sites, directories, your own website), and names the companies that look established, well reviewed, and easy to verify.

There's no ad slot to buy and no trick to pull. The businesses that get named are the ones whose information is easy for a machine to find, read, and trust. Every step here feeds one of those three.

Different assistants read from different places. ChatGPT's search has leaned on Bing's index, Google's AI answers pull from Google's index and Business Profiles, and Perplexity crawls the open web and shows its sources. You're covering a few bases, not one.

02

See where you stand right now (10 minutes)

Before you change anything, run the exact search a customer would run. Open ChatGPT (free account is fine) and paste this, with your trade and town swapped in:

"Who should I hire for drain cleaning in Waukesha, WI? Give me specific company names and tell me why you picked each one."

Run the same question in Perplexity (perplexity.ai, also free) and in a normal Google search, where the AI answer often sits at the top. For each, note three things:

  • Were you named at all? If yes, was the information about you correct (phone, service area, what you do)?
  • Who was named instead of you? Those are the companies whose online presence the machine trusts more today.
  • In Perplexity, click the sources it cites. That's your map. If it cited Google profiles, Yelp, and a competitor's service page, those are the exact places you need to be stronger.
Field note

Save your notes with today's date. You'll rerun the same searches later to see what moved. Without a baseline you're guessing.

03

Fix the two profiles AI leans on most

AI assistants pull business facts from Google and Bing before they read your website. Both profiles are free, and most contractors have a half-finished Google one and no Bing one.

Google first. Go to business.google.com and open Edit profile. Fill every field: primary category (the most specific one, "Plumber" not "Contractor"), secondary categories, hours, phone, website, and the full services list under the Services tab. Use most of the 750-character description and name your actual towns in it ("serving Waukesha, Pewaukee, and Delafield") because the AI reads that text directly.

Then Bing, which matters because ChatGPT's search has drawn on its index. Go to bingplaces.com and choose the option to import your Google Business Profile. It copies everything over and keeps it synced, about five minutes of work. While you're there, confirm your site is in Bing Webmaster Tools (bing.com/webmasters), which can import your Google Search Console setup the same way.

04

Check that AI crawlers can read your website

AI companies send crawlers to read websites, and some hosts and firewalls block them by default. If the bots can't read your site, assistants can only describe you second-hand.

The check takes one minute. Type your domain followed by /robots.txt into a browser, like yourbusiness.com/robots.txt. In the plain text file that appears, look for these names: GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ChatGPT-User, PerplexityBot, ClaudeBot, Google-Extended. Any of them followed by "Disallow: /" means that crawler is banned from your whole site.

A block you didn't put there usually came from your website builder or from Cloudflare, which has a one-click setting that blocks AI crawlers (under Security > Bots). Fix it there, or send whoever built your site this sentence: "Please update robots.txt to allow GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, PerplexityBot, and ClaudeBot."

Field note

For a local service business, your pages are the ad. Letting the bots read them is how you get recommended.

05

Write the page that answers the actual question

Assistants quote pages that state facts plainly. A homepage that says "Quality service you can trust" gives them nothing to work with. A service page that answers the customer's real questions gives them everything.

Build one page per main service. State plainly: what the service covers, the towns you drive to, a real price range if you can commit to one ("most water heater swaps run $1,400-$2,200 installed"), how fast you respond, and your license number. These are the sentences AI answers quote word for word.

Add a short FAQ block at the bottom of each page with questions written the way customers ask them out loud: "Do you charge to come out and look?" "Can you come today?" "Do you handle permits?" Answer each in two or three sentences. Assistants lift this format straight into their answers.

If your site doesn't have LocalBusiness schema yet, add it. It hands machines your name, hours, phone, and service area in a format they read directly, and our schema guide has a copy-paste template.

06

Get talked about in the places AI reads

Assistants don't just read your own pages. They weigh what other people say about you, and you can influence that honestly.

Reviews carry detail, not just stars. When you ask a happy customer for a Google review, ask them to mention the service and town: "mind saying it was a furnace repair in Hartland?" AI answers summarize review text, so that sentence does far more work than a bare five stars.

Keep your name, address, and phone identical everywhere: Google, Bing, Yelp, Angi, BBB, Nextdoor, Facebook. Machines match listings by those three fields, and mismatches make you look like two different half-real companies.

Reddit and local Facebook groups get read too. A past customer naming you in a "who do you recommend" thread can surface in AI answers for years. Never post fake recommendations of yourself; that reads as spam to humans and machines both. After a good job, ask: "if you see someone asking for a recommendation, I'd appreciate the mention."

07

Recheck monthly and keep score

Put a monthly reminder on your calendar and rerun the three searches from step two, same wording. Compare against your notes: named now, information right, sources different?

Still invisible after the profiles, crawler access, and service pages are done? The gap is almost always reviews or mentions. Go back to the Perplexity citations, find the sites it trusts for your trade, and get properly listed on each one.

When you do show up, check what it says. If something's wrong (old phone number, a town you don't serve), trace it to the source, usually a stale directory listing, and fix it there. Assistants repeat what the web says about you, so the web is where you correct them.

Common questions

Questions that come up

Can I pay ChatGPT or Google to recommend my business?

No. There's no paid placement inside the recommendation itself. Ads can appear around AI results, but the companies named in the answer are picked from what the AI finds and trusts on the open web. That's good news for a small shop: the playing field is profiles, reviews, and clear pages, not budget.

How long until I start showing up in AI answers?

There's no fixed timeline and anyone who promises one is guessing. Profile fixes and crawler access can show up quickly because assistants search the live web, while new pages and reviews take longer to build weight. That's why the monthly recheck matters: it tells you what's moving instead of leaving you to wonder.

Should I block AI bots so they can't take my content?

For a local service business, no. Your service pages exist to bring in calls, and AI assistants are now a path customers take to find someone to hire. Blocking the crawlers removes you from that path while your competitors stay on it. Publishers who sell their writing face a different tradeoff; you don't.

Which AI assistant should I focus on first?

Google and ChatGPT, in that order, because that's where the search volume is. The work overlaps almost completely though: a complete Google Business Profile, a synced Bing Places listing, open crawler access, and plain-spoken service pages cover Google's AI answers, ChatGPT, and Perplexity at the same time.

Or skip the homework

Rather I just did this?

Fair. The audit shows where your site actually stands in about a minute, then you decide. No email required, no pressure, just the truth.